Histrionic Personality Disorder vs. Narcissistic Personality Disorder
Both can appear self-centered from the outside, making the distinct underlying psychological driver easy to conflate without careful assessment.
Learn
A pervasive pattern of excessive emotionality and attention-seeking, including discomfort when not the center of attention, rapidly shifting and shallow emotional expression, and a tendency to view relationships as more intimate than they actually are.
People with Histrionic Personality Disorder actively seek to be the center of attention and feel uncomfortable when they are not. Emotional expression tends to be dramatic and rapidly shifting, self-presentation and interaction style can be inappropriately sexually seductive or provocative, speech is often impressionistic and lacking in detail, and the person may be highly suggestible and consider relationships to be closer than they actually are.
As a personality disorder, the pattern is stable and traceable to early adulthood, distinguishing it from situational attention-seeking behavior tied to a specific life circumstance.
Relationships often become strained as others tire of the emotional intensity and perceived superficiality, and the person's discomfort with not being the center of attention can create workplace and social friction.
Rapidly shifting, shallow emotional expression; use of physical appearance to draw attention; and a style of speech that is vivid and impressionistic but lacking in supporting detail are common.
Norms for emotional expressiveness and self-presentation vary substantially across cultures; a culturally normative expressive style should not, on its own, be interpreted as evidence of this disorder.
A common misconception is that any emotionally expressive or dramatic person has this disorder; the diagnosis requires a pervasive pattern causing significant relationship or functional impairment, not simply an expressive personal style.
Reconsider this diagnosis if the pattern is better explained by identity disturbance and abandonment fears (Borderline Personality Disorder) or by grandiosity and need for admiration tied to self-image (Narcissistic Personality Disorder).
A 33-year-old woman consistently steers conversations back to herself at social gatherings, describes new acquaintances as 'my closest friend' after a single meeting, and experiences noticeable distress when attention shifts to someone else in a group setting.
Know
Know the core feature: discomfort when not the center of attention, driving a broader pattern of dramatic, shifting emotional expression.
Notice
Notice a tendency to perceive relationships as more intimate than they actually are, and impressionistic speech lacking supporting detail.
Distinguish
Distinguish from Narcissistic Personality Disorder by the absence of core grandiosity -- histrionic PD centers on being noticed and admired broadly, not on a grandiose self-view specifically.
Recognize
A pervasive, longstanding pattern of attention-seeking, excessive and shifting emotionality, and a self-presentation style oriented around being noticed, present across relationships and contexts.
Distinguish
Distinguish from Narcissistic Personality Disorder by the absence of core grandiosity -- histrionic PD centers on being noticed and admired broadly, not on a grandiose self-view specifically.
Borderline Personality Disorder (both involve attention-seeking and emotional intensity, but borderline PD centers on identity disturbance, abandonment fears, self-harm, and unstable relationships, while histrionic PD centers more specifically on the need to be the center of attention with less of the identity instability), Narcissistic Personality Disorder (both seek admiration, but narcissistic PD centers on grandiosity and a need for admiration tied to self-image, while histrionic PD centers on emotionality and being the center of attention more broadly, without the same grandiose self-view).
Both can appear self-centered from the outside, making the distinct underlying psychological driver easy to conflate without careful assessment.
Both can present with intense, rapidly shifting emotions and a strong pull on others' attention, leading to conflation; screening specifically for self-harm, suicidality, chronic emptiness, and identity disturbance is what distinguishes a Borderline presentation from a Histrionic one.
Both can appear needy of others' engagement, leading to conflation; Histrionic's neediness is expressed through dramatic, attention-drawing behavior, while Dependent's neediness is expressed through submissiveness and reluctance to act independently.
Reason
Apply
Distinguish Histrionic Personality Disorder's broad need for attention and emotional expressiveness from Narcissistic Personality Disorder's grandiosity and need for admiration tied to self-image.
Retrieve
2 question(s) reference this disorder. Practice Histrionic Personality Disorder →
Master